A brutally trustworthy, unbiased evaluate of the York Pottery Barn Couch and what it’s best to know earlier than you buy one.
We’ve been dwelling with our two Pottery Barn sofas for almost 2 MONTHS, so I’m lastly exhibiting and sharing the entire nitty gritty particulars about them!
I prevented exhibiting these sofas since they arrived as a result of I knew I’d instantly get questions in my inbox about them, however I needed to present it time to have a completely formulated opinion about our expertise earlier than ever recommending them to anybody.
Our Slipcovered Slope Arm York Pottery Barn Couch buy occurred after years of debating, ready, and saving up for what we dubbed our “dream couch”.
UPDATE: It’s been a 12 months now and we nonetheless love these sofas! We aren’t fairly as proud of our alternative of Sunbrella cloth and realized we most likely would select Crypton if we may do it over. Right here’s how we clear the Pottery Barn couches.
That is how our couch seems to be 6 months after supply:
If it’s a bit of furnishings in your want listing too, I believed it might assist to share all the pieces it’s best to know earlier than deciding if it’s the fitting couch on your family.
Why We Purchased 2 York Pottery Barn Sofas
We obtained two sofas as a result of we discovered having just one couch in our lounge left no further seating room for once we had household and associates over.
How Our Sofas Remodeled Our Residing Room
First, I want a minute to simply marvel over how far this lounge has come since we moved in.
4+ years in the past…
Holy cannoli, Batman!!!!
Okay, I obtained that out of my system… diving in.
Pottery Barn Couch Assessment: What You Ought to Know
Pottery Barn York Slope Arm Couch Specs
York Couch Fashion
We selected the Pottery Barn York Slope Arm Couch largely due to its deep seat and glossy design with the choice for a bench cushion. It’s easy with clear traces.
The York couch fashion lends itself to transitional adorning, so should you really feel your fashion is not-quite-traditional however not-quite-modern, this couch has an awesome form for suiting each. The slope arm element offers it a barely female attribute.
Slipcovered Couch vs. Upholstered Couch
We had the choice of selecting between the upholstered York Slope Arm couch and the slipcovered. I want the slipcover as a result of it offers us the flexibleness to vary it for a brand new shade or cloth materials, if we would like one thing new with out shopping for a completely new couch. The slipcover additionally lends itself to a extra relaxed cottage fashion.
Couch Material Alternative
Though we had 105 couch cloth choices to select from, I knew instantly that I needed a efficiency cloth to face up towards spills and filth from our youngsters and our canine. So we selected the Sunbrella Efficiency Chenille cloth within the shade Salt.
York Couch Dimensions
One of many greatest components that offered us on this couch was how deep the seat is. We selected the 81″ width, which has a seating depth of twenty-two″. The couch is 36″ excessive, which makes it the right couch for taller individuals. In case you want to “curl up” on a settee, you’ll be able to’t beat the York.
Different Comparable Sofas We Thought-about for Their Glossy Types
Our Residing Surroundings Affecting Sturdiness
We have now two youngsters ages 3 and 9 and a small Yorkie combine canine, so our crew places this sofas to the take a look at BIG TIME.
Our youngsters have already climbed up on the sofas with soiled ft and palms, and our canine loves sitting on the again cushions squishing them off form once I’m not round to inform her no.
Pottery Barn Couch Professionals
- Sturdiness. As a result of the cushions are down mix, they’re simple to “fluff” proper again into form. The unfastened cushions may be flipped to advertise longevity, and the couch is made from a non-sagging metal.
- Consolation. We have now owned 3 sofas prior to now 4 years, one being the IKEA Farlov (which I posted a full evaluate about our IKEA Farlov couch years in the past). I’ll share extra in regards to the Farlov comparability later on this submit, however the Pottery Barn couch is by far absolutely the most comfy. Robert and I’ve sat examined many sofas through the years, and we saved coming again to this one. In case you like a settee you’ll be able to sink into however has simply sufficient help, this one is “good” that Goldilocks would approve of. Many a naps have been had on these sofas as a result of the bench cushion particularly is like laying on a brilliant comfortable twin mattress.
- Customizable design choices. I really like that the York couch line comes with so many choices to customise it on your area, like many different Pottery Barn couch collections: 4 completely different widths, chair and sectional choices, 105 cloth choices, slipcover/upholstery/leather-based choices, flexibility within the variety of again and seat cushions you like, and slope arm possibility for a chic fashion or a sq. arm possibility for a extra fashionable look.
- Simple to wash. We had a few small drink spills with juice and occasional however they scrubbed proper up with water, so the Sunbrella cloth is a winner thus far.
Pottery Barn Couch Cons
- Worth. Okay, right here’s the robust half. It’s not for the low finances crowd. BUT that is a type of you-get-what-you-pay-for conditions, and contemplating the standard of supplies and the truth that the cushions are down mix with Sunbrella cloth, it’s well worth the value in my view. I rely it as an funding. That is our third couch in almost 5 years as a result of the primary two cheaper sofas has polyester fill cushions that ultimately broke down and sagged, springs popped unfastened, and our final one even contributed to a nasty again difficulty for Robert requiring visits to the chiropractor.
- The wait. To be truthful, we’re within the midst of a worldwide provide chain droop, so the lead time difficulty was seemingly a lot worse than it might be in “regular” instances. We ordered these sofas in January 2021, and so they arrived initially of September. It was irritating however ended up being well worth the wait.
- Awkward for sitting up. In conditions once I don’t wish to “curl up” and would quite sit, I do should tuck a few pillows behind me to take a seat upright. In social conditions the place you wish to be a little bit extra formal when company are visiting, it’s a bit awkward. That is positively an off-the-cuff lounging type of sofa.
- Cushions want occasional cleansing. I’ve observed the seat cushions are beginning to look a tiny bit dingy, so going over them with an upholstery cleansing machine (I’ve this upholstery cleaner) with out steaming utilizing water solely may help.
UPDATE: 1 12 months into proudly owning our sofas – the Sunbrella cloth isn’t as simple to maintain clear as I anticipated. I’ve heard from associates who’ve skilled Sunbrella and Crypton materials on different furnishings that they’re a lot happier with Crypton. The Sunbrella does okay and largely cleans up spots with water, however they do nonetheless look dingy with no common swipe of the upholstery cleaner as soon as a month.
See that one little spot on the cushion? The Sunbrella cloth isn’t fully invincible, nevertheless it does clear up simply with simply water and a rag.
Pottery Barn York Couch vs IKEA Farlov Couch
We owned the IKEA Farlov couch with a white slipcover for about 2 years once we first moved into our home, and the fashion and form is similar to the Pottery Barn York Couch, so now that we’ve got lived with each for some time, right here’s how they examine.
- Consolation. The IKEA Farlov has foam cushions which might be way more agency than the down mix Pottery Barn York cushions. The Farlov remains to be quite comfy for the worth, however the Pottery Barn positively beats it by far.
- Worth. Relying on the kind of cloth you select, the IKEA Farlov is roughly $1400 cheaper than the Pottery Barn couch.
- Material. Over time, my white cotton IKEA slipcover shrunk and have become soiled trying to the purpose the place I couldn’t clear out a few of the stains. The Sunbrella cloth of the Pottery Barn couch is way more sturdy over time with out the shrinking difficulty, particularly since they don’t require washing just like the IKEA slipcovers do.
- Lead Time. As a result of the IKEA Farlov isn’t customized, we have been in a position to purchase ours proper within the retailer and take it home the identical day whereas we needed to wait 9 months for our Pottery Barn couch to be delivered. So the IKEA Farlov is greatest should you want a brand new couch in a rush.
- The Look. The Pottery Barn couch positively seems to be extra “excessive finish” in particular person than the IKEA Farlov just because the standard of supplies is significantly better. The down mix cushions look extra “fluffy” and the material seems to be extra luxurious than the cotton slipcover of the Farlov.
- Dimension. The IKEA Farlov sits about 2 inches decrease to the ground and the Pottery Barn couch can be 4 inches deeper, so the Farlov isn’t fairly as nicely suited to tall individuals.
- Customizable Choices. With the IKEA Farlov couch, the material decisions are restricted to 4 varieties/colours (although you should buy upgraded slipcovers for the Farlov from Bemz or Consolation Works). The Pottery Barn couch has 105 cloth decisions with completely different ranges of sturdiness efficiency to fit your family’s wants.
All in all, we’ve got completely zero regrets with our York sofas thus far. They’re actually an funding, one which we didn’t take into account calmly. However I might quite purchase a costlier couch as soon as and have it final a few many years versus shopping for a less expensive couch 3 times in the identical timeframe.
High quality wins out each time in relation to sofas, particularly in a household that makes use of and abuses them.
Pottery Barn Tyler Recliner Assessment
You’ll be able to learn our Pottery Barn Tyler Recliner evaluate right here from a few months in the past too. We nonetheless completely love them!
Okay, another earlier than and after for the highway…
Do you’ve a lounge couch you completely love and suggest? Or do you a Pottery Barn couch you don’t thoughts sharing your expertise about? I’d like to know!
In case you do ultimately resolve to go along with a Pottery Barn couch, it’s greatest to carry out for a 20-30% off sale since they’ve a number of gross sales yearly.
And in case you have any questions on it, ask away.
I’ll be sure you report again as we put on in these sofas extra with time, however thus far, we’re in love!
If you wish to save this submit to reference later, you’ll be able to pin it right here: